Pacifica Black Liquid Eyeliner Pen - Liquid Line - Felt tip, Smudge Proof Eyeliner - Water Resistant Gel Makeup Eye Liner - Matte Fine Tip Clean Beauty Vegan & Cruelty-Free Dermatologist Tested

As long as you keep in mind it's made with natural ingredients, so may not be as dark or bold as some popular brand eyeliners, it is actually really great! Love that I can wear it all day in the Florida heat and an intense job without it bleeding or leaving dark smudges under my eye. Love it!

I love most Pacifica products, but this is the second time I’ve bought this eyeliner and I won’t be doing a third purchase. The pigmentation is very weak and it wears off quickly. It also runs out super fast and the tip was weirdly fuzzy when I went to use it after a few days. Definitely not a good value for the price.

Easy to apply, soft look, stays on all day and is clean. Ran out pretty quickly.

I like how natural this is (gets a great rating on Yuka) but it bleeds and spreads significantly and I can wipe it off very easily. Tears will definitely make this disappear.

The media could not be loaded. Yes, the stain may not be as dark as your regular eyeliner ,BUT the ingredients for this eyeliner definitely makes it worth buying. With a score of 93/100 on the yuka app i will never buy any other eyeliner. Other liners are made from harsh chemicals and know carcinogens. It's hard to find a charcoal eyeliner in pen form so this one will always be my favorite.

I was only able to use this about 2 times before the color ran out. Now it's just light grey liquid that comes out. Do not buy. Not durable. Very invaluable for the price and now I wasted money being that I can't return it.

I loved it the first week. But, since I applied it after applying eyeshadow the felt tip would absorb the powder and would not apply properly. After the second week the Color faded to a dark grey and I was having to apply a second and third coat to get the same effect that I had the first week.

Beautiful and well defined lines. It’s a great product!