Supernatural Plant-Based Food Coloring - Red & Green Natural Food Dye Powders, Hyper-Concentrated, Vegan, No Artificial Dyes for Holiday Baking (4 Packets)

These work well. Nice colors. I dissolved them in the smallest amount of hot water. It would be nice if they had a resealable package. Also, green or blue to make green would be nice. (Green in the attached photo is not from this set. All other colors are.)

We are so glad we order this and we were able to make an adorable Spider-Man cake for my son’s birthday! It took multiple to get the color, but totally worth it! It is natural and doesn’t change the taste of the icing!

Used this for royal icing and was very happy! Red is a hard color to achieve!

Everything about colors, I thought this was a great option. All Natural ingredients. Just to make you aware, if you are a have to have super bright, this isn't for you. But they make pretty colors. These are nice. Just wish for the price they offered a full bottle size.

I was using this for a layered rainbow cake for my 3 yr old’s birthday. I used two boxes of gluten free cake mix, 8 eggs, and two sticks of butter that is now all in the garbage. I wasted hours mixing the colors to get the right colors. Yes, hours. I have a fine art degree so it is not for a lack of color theory knowledge. These are just difficult and faulty to work with. Once I finally achieved the colors, the batter looked really good except for the purple kept turning blue as it sat, when mixed again, it would turn back to purple. So right before putting it in the oven, I mixed it to purple. It ended up baking into a blue color. This was especially disappointing since it was the most important color since it is my daughter’s favorite color and I spent the most time mixing it since it was at first gray looking. The red was a strong color raw but once baked ALL of the color baked out of it!! Same with green.Then the blue had to be mixed using baking soda. Again, raw- it looked great, but once baked it was washed out to basically colorless. My kids tasted that cake layer, the baking soda taste was so prevalent and therefore totally inedible. Another layer in the trash! All of the colors failed except for the orange and yellow. The orange changed a lot once baked, but I will still use it along with the yellow just so I don't need to use a 4th box of cake mix. Both are lighter than the raw batter color but I am salvaging them at the very least. I was literally almost in tears after using this failed product. So much time and money wasted. Gf cake mixes are $8 a box. I ended up needing 3 boxes plus the cost of the “dye” . The time wasted acting like a mad scientist to get the right blue and purple was borderline insane, hours literally hours wasted on this cake that is now in the trash.I see most of the reviews are for icing and frostings, so it may work for that, but please do not waste your time and money if you are baking a cake!In the attached photos, the blue baked layer was the purple batter. The red layer you can see once cut and leveled is colorless inside. The last cake layer image is the green. The blue was already in the trash, so no photo, but looked the same as the green.

I especially appreciated the depth and color of the natural red derived from Pomegranates. No bad tastes as occurs with Beets.

If you’re looking for a good ingredient plant based food coloring instead of chemicals you found it. it doesn’t change the taste and it does color like normal food coloring. The issue we had was once you bake with it, it looses color. For example, we made some “red velvet” more like “fuchsia velvet” cupcake and they were beautiful but once baked they came out more like a very pale pink / light chocolate cupcake. They still tasted great. But if you know that it’s cooking with powdered Whole Foods basically you should expect a change at temperature.Overall happy with product. Will buy again and use for frosting or coloring things that don’t need a bake.

I have to say I was pleasantly surprised by how well these worked - the colors were vibrant and true to color (used to color icing). I would definitely recommend this item if you want something less toxic than regular food coloring.