Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner - Black Vinyl (0.03 Fl. Oz.) Vegan, Cruelty-Free Liquid Eyeliner to Define & Intensify Eyes for Long-Lasting Wear

Yesss! These are so cheap, and are super good. Well, I actually got this for my girlfriend and she seems to really really like them. Which makes me really really happy. She was looking around for something cheaper than the one she already uses with is I believe M.A.C. which is pretty pricy, and so she was looking for something cheaper. When she was browsing around I saw these with her and offered to get it for her just because it was so cheap. She agreed, and it came quickly.We opened the box and I gave it to her. She immediately put it on my face. I asked her what she was doing and she said in case it irritates skin. I waited a bit and no irritation! Yay! I live to tell another tale. Anywho, after that I watched as she effortlessly applied this to her eye. I watched in anticipation. Just waiting for her to mess up and poke her eye out or something! Yet none of this happened. Instead what I was greated with were some on point, super crisp, and delish looking cat eyes! Yeahhhh my favorite! HahaIn all seriousness, though, these are really good. Well that's what my girlfriend tells me at least. She wears it every day and hasn't irritated her sensitive skin. It comes out smooth and comes out whenever you need it do I think! She just says it's really good and she really likes it. It really makes some nice lines. You could even use this for calligraphy!! That's what these remind me of at-least.Anywho my personal opinion is that these are fantastic! Makes my girlfriend's cat eyes, eyeliner, things look super clean and sharp! OH Also they don't smear and seem to be slightly sweat/water-proof. They definitely do not smear easily. Especially with some intense face rubbing!

I LOVE LOVE LOVE this eyeliner. I was a very early convert to the liquid eyeliner revival back in 2008, so I have been through a number of different products in my time. I started with Urban Decay's liquid eyeliner, which was first in a small pot with a brush, and then it changed and was only okay. Eventually Stila came out with their pen, and since Stila can do no wrong with me, I tried it and was instantly converted. That is also a great product, and I wouldn't have stopped using it except that I decided to only use cruelty-free cosmetics. That Stila eyeliner was the only product I missed...until I found Milani's eyeliner pen. I saw an infographic on Pinterest demonstrating cruelty-free alternatives to cult favorite beauty products, and immediately bought this pen. (I had gone back to Urban Decay, and I was not impressed with the quality.) It's smooth, easy to apply, super precise, and has a gripper on the pen. It's nice and dark, and it's CRUELTY-FREE. Honestly, I don't notice a difference from the Stila product. Even better, it's half the cost of the Stila pen! I am such a huge fan of this product, and I will absolutely recommend it to anyone who asks.

This product was horrible. I initially purchased this product as it was highly recommended by a friend and had very high ratings on amazon, however I was thoroughly disappointed. The product was SUPER watery therefore it took a long time to dry. As I have monolids, this means that if I were to open my eyes right away it would rub everywhere. Then it barely lasted even after it dried. It was splotchy and would run into my eyes throughout the day and sting my eyes. I heard from my friend that this is not how the eyeliner typically is (perhaps I go a bad batch?) but I don't want to spend the money and find out that I go another "bad one". I wouldn't recommend this at all.

I really love this liner. It is a liquid liner with a felt tip applicator. Although this product does not say waterproof it stays on all day with a deep rich black.(Has a semi-reflective finish, not matte) I applied some to my hand the night before I used it first on my eyes to see if I would have an allergic reaction or if it would flake off. It went on very smooth/sharp and stayed on until the next morning enduring hand washing and a nightly face wash. No flaking or rubbing off.Will need makeup remover or coconut oil to completely remove.The only thing I would say is that to achieve a very fine line you have to use the very end of the tip lightly. If you hold it slanted with the angle of your eye it gives a thicker line (which I like) So if you are looking for very fine clean lines, with this product it would be hard to achieve.This product would be perfect for applying eyeliner between the natural lash line and your false lashesOverall good product and will repurchase.

Liquid eye liners (felt tip one especially) tend to dry out very quick, so I like finding a good one at a bargain price.This one applies a dark black line, smoothly and without patches (but not jet black). The felt tip is quite long, but I got used to it quickly. I can draw finer lines, flick or thick wings (and I'm not eyeliner expert). It lasts all day, but I won't call it completely waterproof. I have hooded eyes and a finer line does not transfer during the day.I store it flat and I get a nice application each time. After a month or two (depending on how often I use it) the felt starts to collect eye shadow and dry out; application becomes uneven (I can barely finish one eye) and pigmentation is patchy.It's not the best, but even with more expensive product I still need a new one every 1-2 months; so I would rather pay the smaller price.

GREAT LINER. I freaking love this thing. it is honestly better than I had expected. It's black. Like marker black. It stays that way all day, and it goes on SO EASILY. I've had liquid liners that you had to brush on like nail polish, and ones that were "black" but appeared grey. This eye liner is perfect. You draw right on your lid, like it's a marker, and it's extremely rich in color. I will definitely keep buying these liquid eye liners. I was drawing on my arm with it because it's so nice. I should have taken a picture to show you all, but I just thought of that...