Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover & Cleanser for Sensitive Eyes, Non-Greasy Makeup Remover, Waterproof Mascara Remover, Dermatologist & Ophthalmologist Tested, 3.8 fl. oz

I've been using this product for years. It's the best one I've found at a reasonable price that will easily remove make-up, even waterproof mascara, without irritating my eyes or skin. It's just a slightly bit oily, barely noticeable. I have no trouble putting in my contact lenses right after I use it.

This my favorite eye makeup remover. Pretty sure it's the same formula as the old Clean and Clear one that I used for years. It's gentle on my sensitive eyes and never burns. Leaves a little bit of an oily feeling, but it's moisturizing rather than greasy. You gotta shake it up a little bit before using it, but this stuff works great for getting off waterproof formulas. Just put some on a cotton round and hold the pad down on your eyelid for a little bit before wiping off. It's also worked really well for removing long-wear lipstick!

This stuff works great. Gets is all off, even the waterproof stuff. I really like it. Will buy again.

Just a tip before getting into the pros/cons: you will want to have cotton balls, cotton rounds, or something similar on hand to apply this to. I've been using this for years and toilet paper of any kind has always fallen apart, piling and leaving little bits of TP residue behind.Pros:- Works well. A small amount takes off all of my makeup, though it does struggle a little with some extremely waterproof Japanese mascara. A little extra is still able to remove that.- Uses silcones rather than oil, so if you're prone to acne, it should not cause any comedogenic reactions.- Inexpensive. From those I have seen and priced, this is quite a bit cheaper than using pre-soaked makeup remover wipes. You also don't have to worry about it drying out, unlike the wipes.- A little bit goes a pretty long way. I use this about four times per week and a bottle lasts about two months.Cons:- Can have a greasy afterfeel from the silicones. Even if you spread this out, it feels unpleasantly greasy and takes upwards of 5 minutes to sink in. Instead, I often follow it with a chemical exfoliant like mild Stridex (.05% salicylic acid). It's a nice addition to my skincare routine and cuts that unpleasant greasiness.

Removes waterproof mascara without rubbing. Easy on delicate skin around the eyes. A little goes a long way!

Great product for gently removing eye makeup and mascara.

Neutrogena Oil-Free Liquid Eye Makeup Remover is a game-changer for anyone seeking a gentle and effective solution for removing stubborn eye makeup. Its oil-free formula effortlessly dissolves even the most stubborn waterproof mascara and eyeliner without leaving behind a greasy residue. The gentle nature of this remover ensures it is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, as it doesn't cause any irritation or stinging. The convenient flip-top bottle allows for easy dispensing, preventing any unnecessary spills or waste. Overall, this eye makeup remover lives up to its reputation, leaving your eyes clean, refreshed, and makeup-free with minimal effort.

I'm actually a little disappointed! I remember this being one of my all-time favorite eye makeup removers from high school. I guess high school me didn't know what she was talking about. That isn't to say that this is terrible! It does work just fine, and I like it. I'll break it down into three sections to elaborate:QUALITY: Neutrogena is my go-to company for skincare, generally speaking. Almost all of my products are from them. They're easy to find, affordable, and generally work great. This gets a three star instead of a four star because I think it's lower quality than the rest of their products. I'm just... not impressed. Why? Glad you asked! You see...FEEL: It's oily. Oily, oily, oily. My skin feels like an oil slick after I'm done, honestly. This doesn't matter THAT much because it's removing eye make-up. I just really hate the feeling of it, and it feels sticky and heavy until I wash the rest of it off my lid. If your skin is prone to breakouts, I wouldn't recommend this product. It's funny, because it says it's "oil-free", but I swear it's chock full! It feels awful! But...EFFICIENCY: Like I mentioned, it DOES get the job done in true Neutrogena fashion. If you're okay with the discomfort of having an awful-feeling product leaving a gross residue on your eye... then I guess it's worth it! I guess I'll leave it at this: I WILL be using the entirety of the product, but I will NOT be buying it again. I'll try something different next time. Oh, Neutrogena, you've let me down this time!