e.l.f. Liquid Eyeliner, High-pigment Liquid Eyeliner With Extra-Fine Brush Tip, Easy Glide Smudge-proof Formula, Charcoal

Simply fantastic eye liner. I have tried more expensive brands that weren't as good. So easy to apply with the brush and it stays put for long enough. if it does droop a little I just wipe a bit with my fingertip and reapply if necessary, but it lasts at least 6 hours without worrying about that. If you want a good eye liner for the money this is it.

I’ve been using elf eyeliner since middle school and I don’t think I’ll ever switch to another brand. It’s always held up for me and is versatile for any look. It’s very smooth application with the brush tip. I am happy it is the only eyeliner I love as most have a felt tip that makes the eyeliner thick. It does smudge sometimes only if you rub it but other than that it does last and is easy to take off at the end of the day.

Literally the only eyeliner I will ever buy, it is so cheap and lasts 8+ hours. I clean for a living, so naturally I move and sweat a lot- this eyeliner doesn’t budge or flake. The color is a nice deep black and has the perfect brush for getting a precise wing. Can’t recommend it enough 🩷

**Pros:**- **High-Pigmented**: Offers a rich, jet-black color.- **Extra-Fine Tip**: Ensures precise application.- **Long-Lasting**: Stays on throughout the day.- **Vegan & Cruelty-Free**: Ethical and responsible choice.**Cons:**- **Minor Flaws**: While it's mostly great, there are occasional issues with the liner drying out quickly or the tip becoming frayed with extended use.

I finally found a liquid eyeliner that doesn't fade off during the course of the day. I can wear it for 8 - 10 hours with no flake off. Easy smooth application which dries quickly. Very easy to take off with makeup remover at end of day. I bought black and it's not a heavy looking black.

This is a great product. Goes on easy and lasts.

My go to, easy to use, makes the thinnest line. Great price for great quality.

I'm 47 and have needed truly waterproof, sweat-proof, oil-proof, everything-proof eye makeup for about 10 years. I have found liquid eyeliner to be the absolute best at 16-hour + wear, but I hate hate hate a felt tip, it has to be a real brush. So I was very excited to try this, as I love this brand, and it's affordability (actually use their mascara, and it stays put). It went on like a dream at 6 am, but by 2 pm I could see it... black fade under my eyes. Sadly I bought a pack of two and won't be able to use them.