COLORGRAM Artist Formula Cream Liner - 05 Choco Brown | Cream Eyeliner, Ultra-pigmented, Long-Lasting, Smudge-Proof, Easy to Use, Daily Makeup 0.25g | Coachella Makeup, Spring Makeup

I saw that this came recommended from Pony, the Youtube makeup artist, and was on the hunt for a brown eyeliner that wasn't so dark. OMG. As someone with oily eyelids who can't even manage to make eyeshadow last for more than an hour, this thing doesn't budge. It's truly a cream liner as even whilst swatching it glided on smoothly on the back of my skin. But it barely took a few seconds to set and as I tried to wipe it off with my hands, a wet wipe, and tissue, it wouldn't move unless I used an oil cleanser. Do get this and try it.

Was looking for a good thin liner for my waterline and just do a eyeliner in general. The BEST one i have tried, the formula is pretty creamy which makes it go on super smooth does not smudge at all once it dries for 30 sec or so. Would recommend to buy!

I wish eyeliner was a little creamier and smoother to apply. It does have staying power though, so we will see how long product will last. Pencil is a little small.

this is one of my favorite liners it’s very smooth and buttery which i often have trouble finding in a liner. it creates very nice smooth thin lines and very easy to use. However if you’re like me and have oily eyelids you may need to have a good powder base before applying or it can rub off later in the day. i will be repurchasing when i run out.

Soo pretty and very pigmented a little goes a long way!!! Will buy more for sure !! Highly reccomend