e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine, Conditioning & Nourishing Lip Balm, Sheer Color Tinted Lip Moisturizer, Giddy, 0.09 Oz

As a long-time user of Clinique's iconic Black Honey Almost Lipstick, I was intrigued when I stumbled upon E.l.f.'s Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic. At first glance, the two shades appear remarkably similar, and upon application, the resemblance is even more striking. However, it's the price difference that truly caught my attention. While Black Honey can cost anywhere from $20 to $25, this E.l.f. gem is a fraction of the price, making it an incredibly affordable option.One of the standout features of the E.l.f. lip shine is its impressive hydration. The heart-shaped core delivers a burst of moisture, leaving my lips feeling soft, supple, and nourished, especially during the harsh winter months. In comparison, I've found Black Honey to be slightly less hydrating, particularly in drier climates.While both products offer a beautiful, universally flattering shade, E.l.f.'s formula provides a more sheer, buildable finish. This makes it versatile for various occasions, from a subtle daytime look to a more intense evening look.In conclusion, E.l.f.'s Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic is a fantastic dupe for Clinique's Black Honey. It offers comparable color payoff, superior hydration, and an unbeatable price point. If you're a fan of the classic Black Honey shade, I highly recommend giving this E.l.f. product a try. Just be prepared to stock up, as it's likely to fly off the shelves!

I love this. It’s a super pretty color. I was trying to find something close to Black Honey, and while I wouldn’t say it’s an exact match, it’s still very pretty. It’s also really moisturizing and feels great on the lips. I use it often.

For the price point, this is an incredible product. It is moisturizing, the color is a reasonable substitute for Clinique Black Honey — not a dupe but close — and while it has a fruity fragrance when applied, that dissipates quickly. It’s not sticky or color changing, and in fact the pigment stays better than a lot of other products with a moisturizing core. It’s comfortable to wear. I’d buy this again.

I had seen a few reviews about this being a good dupe for the color Arwen wore in LOTR. I don't know how close it is or not but the color is lovely and the quality is good. I feel 30 percent prettier wearing it.

This product is alright. You can get better ones was a similar price.Has a very weird and annoying smell to it. The tint was really good and it moisturized the lips but the smell made it hard to have it on for long. I would end up washing it off to remove the smell that made me nauseous.

This feels so nice and creamy on my lips. I love putting it on. There is some gloss but not much color, just a hint. It's not as colorful as a lipstick would be. It's for when you want something more subtle.

The size is just right, and it's smooth on the lips. I got the color Lovely, and it tastes like melon. It has good hydration and a nice pigment color.

This balm in the color Lovely is exactly that: lovely! I do like the way this feels and looks on my lips. I specifically bought it to wear over a lip liner that I find especially pretty. I slightly over-line my lips, then color them in. The color is very beautiful, but my poor lips feel very dry, and there is a very dry, matte finish which is not what I want. So I apply this over the pencil and it provides a soft shine and makes my lips feel more hydrated.The only downside for me is the scent and taste! I think this is supposed to mimic pineapple. I like pineapple as much as the next person, but I would be much happier without this artificial flavor and scent! Still I put up with it because it looks so pretty, and is so comfortable on. I’d buy it again.