Kaely Rose Pink Longwear Liquid Lip Liner Waterproof, 24 Hour Long Lasting Lip Liner Stain Marker Pen, 2-in-1 Matte Semi Permanent Lipliner & Lipstick, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, 04

I am giving these 5 stars because they were exactly as described. I however did not like them and it was my fault for not reading that they are tattoo liners and not the peelable kind. They stay really well though and they are bold! They are kind of dry once they dry if that makes sense. But they do stay on well.

Disappointed, beautiful color but poor quality!The colors of this product are absolutely beautiful, and when I first used it, it stayed on for a very long time. I was really happy with how well it matched my skin tone and how my lips looked. Unfortunately, I only got to use it once. By the next day, the pencil had dried out completely, even though I had closed it properly and stored it in a cool area. I had planned to use it for an event, but it was no longer usable.I'm very disappointed. Although I could return it, I don't think its worth replacing. I feel like I wasted my money. Its such a shame because it had great potential, but the quality just didn't hold up.

I have this liner in 3 shades. It goes on nicely and smoothly, and dries quickly. I have thin lips and like to line just a tad over the line (no "Lucy Lips" here). It matches well with the Maybelline Superstay Teddy Tints I bought them to go with. The reason for only 3 stars because after about 2-3 hours, it will start to crack. I am SO disappointed, as they match perfectly. I got them for 5.99, so I'm on the fence as to whether I will bother to send them back.As for the colors, I got the Cherry Red, but it is a deep burgundy. Almost brown. I was hoping for a nice red. The Orchid is pretty true to an orchid color (a pinky/lavender). The Deep Red is a wine-ish shade. I am disappointed in the quality, and will not re-purchase, but I guess at the price point, I was expecting more.

Why did you pick this product vs others?:Too dark when applied. I would not consider this a "cherry" red.

They work great. Color is awesome and lasts all day.

This 3-pack of liquid lip liners goes on smoothly and the colors are attractive, though a bit different from the pictures. Unfortunately, they don’t live up to the “long wear” claim but they start to fade or come off shortly after applying. Decent for short wear, but not reliable for all-day use.

Love the ease of application as the liquid formula glides on, the color lasts even when drinking out of a glass, and the colors are pretty. I bought the multipack that had #3, #5, and #7. My favorite is #7 which is a pretty rose color. The #5 is a peachy nude but it doesn't look natural (at least on me), and the #3 is a pretty dark mauve color. As you can tell, none of them have names, only numbers (names would be helpful), and even on the actual product, there is no mention of name or number. If you did a color swatch on your wrist, you would have to rub the area pretty hard to remove the color. Overall, I really like the product and would like to try more products from this manufacturer!

Maybe an allergy, but it burned and tingled on applying. Stored it in proper position vertically but this product also appears to have very little content.