12 Colors Lip Liner Set, Matte Finish Series Lip Liners Pen Kit for Women, Long Lasting Waterproof Smooth High Pigmented Lip Pencil for Daily Makeup (Set B)

Color variety was great. They last decently long, not completely smudge proof though if you’re looking for something that absolutely will not budge. These aren’t it but good quality.

I’m enjoying several different colors that I like to use matching my outfit! Price is right! Thank you! Amazing work and great execution! Thank you Amazon company to provide for this your customers 👍

Just average. The colors are fine, but they don’t draw on smoothly. The pencils are hard and the color doesn’t last long. They were highly rated, but I don’t see it. I would not recommend. A younger person might be ok with it, but as a 60+ year old, I’m looking for better quality.

OH MY GOODNESS these lip liners are easy to apply and the color is bold! It’s lasts for a good bit but I did notice it smudge a little bit. But it’s so cute! And my lips stay colorful all day at work 🙏

These are amazing! I am a professional makeup artist usually using the Makeup Forever artist color pencils- anywhere caffeine and endless cacao- iykyk. These are a great dupe for those pencils as far as texture and I think they might even last longer! For the price, buy them you won’t be sorry.