Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped - Salt Water Taffy Candy, Old Fashioned Assorted Flavors, Soft and Chewy Candy Mix, Gluten Free Variety Pack - 14 oz Bag

I had a craving for salt water taffy and ordered the Sweet Candy Company Salt Water Taffy here on Amazon. I was impressed right away—the candy arrived well-packaged, fresh, and soft, not hard or stale like some taffy can be. The variety of flavors was excellent, with each one tasting distinct and delicious. They were so good that I couldn’t stop snacking, and the whole bag only lasted a couple of days.The pieces are the perfect size—chewy without being sticky—and the texture is exactly what good salt water taffy should be. It reminded me of buying taffy at the beach as a kid, only now it’s conveniently delivered to my door. Overall, these were fresh, tasty, and a great value for the quality. I’ll definitely be buying them again, and I highly recommend them to anyone who loves salt water taffy.

I read all the reviews prior to ordering and took a chance. As far as I’m concerned, I wasn’t talking a chance, because it was obvious those complainers had no idea what taffy is all about. Hard? No, but it’s more firm until you put it into your warm mouth and start to chew. Stick to wrapping paper? Normal that it’ll stick some. You expect the seller to wrap them in Teflon lined paper? LOL!! No flavor? If you can’t taste the flavors, do yourself a favor and make an appointment to have All your senses checked out. The flavors are great! I’m sure there are other taffies out there with more flavor, but probably cost 2 or 3 times more.I’ll reorder soon and have recommended it to others.Great value for what you get.

Delicious taffy! Soft, chewy, and full of classic flavor—just like the old-fashioned salt water taffy I remember. The 3 lb bag comes with a great mix of flavors, all individually wrapped and super fresh. Perfect for parties, candy jars, or just snacking. Great value for the amount you get—highly recommend for anyone who loves taffy!

I was looking for fresh,soft and chewy and these are perfect.... And taste? Perfect again. Full of flavor. I will definitely buy again.

Taste great. Good consistency. We cut them up and use in our freeze dryer. They come out perfect!

The candy arrived stuck together and unable to unwrap the candies. Must have been left in a hot environment. I have to go and return for a refund -- a nuisance due to defective product.

Artificially flavored and many pieces are melted and stuck together so I couldn't get them out of the wrapper. They tasted good but the wrappers didn't come clean and much of the taffy stuck to it. I'm returning one bag and will keep looking for an authentic taffy. This isn't it!

Some of the previous reviews had me a bit concerned. Though the taffy is good ! 🍬 Not too hard/stale, not so soft it’s sticking to the wrapper, good flavor. If you want a softer taffy, roll between your hands or sit on it for a minute or so 🍭 Just wish there were more flavor varieties ! 🌈 Though they do show what you get in the photo, so that is fair. From what I can see this is the best value for money on Amazon currently. I ordered a 3lb amount on 06/02/2025 for 22.99$ 🤍